2025 On3 True Freshman All-American Team

by: Charles Power 12/08/25 CharlesPower

With the 2025 college football regular season in the books, On3 has unveiled its True Freshman All-American Team, highlighting the nation’s top first-year standouts. While many highly touted recruits made an impact this fall, a select few separated themselves from the pack.

Miami wide receiver Malachi Toney earns Offensive True Freshman of the Year honors after emerging as one of the most productive young playmakers in the country, while LSU cornerback DJ Pickett takes home Defensive True Freshman of the Year recognition following an outstanding debut season in Baton Rouge.

Several others delivered standout seasons of their own, making for one of the deepest and most talented true freshman classes in recent years.

The On3 True Freshman All-American Team is listed below, with full commentary on each selection.

Read More