Grading all 32 first-round picks from 2025 NFL Draft: Which high-profile rookies have thrived? Flopped?

Copied!

The 2025 NFL regular season has less than a month remaining, but the rookie class is just starting its journey in the league. The first-round picks — those ballyhooed prospects who were expected to transform their respective teams — have logged enough snaps for executives, scouts and coaches to assess their development as plus starters or key contributors.

While draft position is expected to correlate with potential impact, the grading scale is subjective, based on the roster makeup and how the rookie contributed to the team’s efforts through three-quarters of the season. Additionally, the first-year grade does not mean the prospect is a potential bust; it is part of a three-year evaluation that will ultimately determine whether the franchise exercises the fifth-year option and/or signs the player to a second contract.

After taking a long look at the film and stat sheets, here are my thoughts on the 32 first-rounders from the 2025 rookie class.

The chaos around the No. 1 overall pick has clouded his evaluation, but the weekly big-play flashes suggest his tools could translate into superstardom in the near future.

Read More