By Gee Bino | The Who Dat Daily
The New Orleans Saints can measure progress through Tyler Shough’s statistics, Kellen Moore’s offensive rankings and the final standings. However, one test will reveal more about this team than almost any other.
Can the Saints finally beat the Atlanta Falcons?
Moore and Shough are 0–2 against New Orleans’ oldest rival. Atlanta swept the Saints in 2025 without dominating either game statistically. Instead, the Falcons capitalized on failed goal-line plays, damaging turnovers and New Orleans’ inability to finish critical drives.
The first loss was embarrassing. The second was heartbreaking.
The Saints now have another year in Moore’s offense, a more experienced quarterback and significantly more firepower surrounding him. Travis Etienne Jr. has joined Alvin Kamara in the backfield. First-round receiver Jordyn Tyson gives Shough another dynamic target opposite Chris Olave. Rookie tight end Oscar Delp adds athleticism and blocking potential.
When Atlanta enters the Caesars Superdome for Monday Night Football on October 5, the excuses must end.
The Falcons beat a developing Saints team twice last season. If Moore and Shough are prepared to lead New Orleans into NFC South contention, they must prove those lessons were learned.
Atlanta Won Because the Saints Failed to Finish
The Falcons did not overwhelm New Orleans during the 2025 season.
In Week 12, Atlanta held only a 302–293 advantage in total yardage. The Saints controlled possession for 32 minutes and 51 seconds but finished 0-for-3 in the red zone.
New Orleans reached the 1-yard line twice without scoring a touchdown.
That failure defined the 24–10 loss.
Moore called a shotgun run near the goal line that resulted in a high snap sailing over Taysom Hill’s head. The Saints also failed on fourth-and-1 and later settled for a short field goal after receiving first-and-goal from the 1-yard line.
Hill is no longer on the roster, but the failed play remains an important lesson. New Orleans turned a basic short-yardage situation into an unnecessarily complicated assignment.
The problems began much earlier.
On the Saints’ second offensive play, Shough struck Kamara’s elbow during a handoff exchange. Atlanta recovered the fumble and converted the short field into three points. Kamara later suffered a knee injury that removed him from the game.
Shough completed 30 of 43 passes for 243 yards, but New Orleans never established offensive control. A fourth-quarter coverage breakdown allowed Kirk Cousins to find Darnell Mooney for a 49-yard touchdown that ended any realistic comeback attempt.
The Falcons did not force the Saints to play perfectly. New Orleans simply made too many mistakes to win.
The Second Loss Was Even More Painful
The Week 18 rematch provided evidence that Shough could eventually lead the Saints past Atlanta.
It also delivered another painful reminder about protecting the football.
New Orleans outgained Atlanta 340–208. The Saints held Bijan Robinson to 33 yards on 15 carries, sacked Cousins four times and limited the Falcons to four third-down conversions on 14 attempts.
Those numbers normally produce a victory.
Instead, the Saints lost 19–17.
Shough played without seven offensive starters and lost Kelvin Banks Jr. to an injury during the game. Despite the depleted lineup, he completed 23 of 35 passes for 259 yards. He also rushed for 34 yards and one touchdown.
With 3:14 remaining, however, Shough threw an interception while New Orleans was threatening to score.
Atlanta converted the mistake into the deciding field goal.
Shough responded by throwing a 16-yard touchdown pass to Ronnie Bell with 1:11 remaining, but the Falcons recovered the onside kick and completed the season sweep.
The rally demonstrated toughness. The interception demonstrated how one decision can erase an afternoon of quality quarterback play.
The Real Concern: Pressure Becoming Sacks
Shough’s rookie season revealed one technical weakness that Moore must continue addressing.
His 25-percent pressure-to-sack rate ranked among the NFL’s worst. When the pocket collapsed, Shough too often held the football instead of finding an escape route, checking the ball down or throwing it away.
That does not mean Shough was naturally a slow processor.
His average time to throw was approximately 2.7 seconds, placing him among the league’s quicker quarterbacks. The problem appeared when the initial structure broke down. Shough could execute the designed progression on schedule, but pressure sometimes disrupted his internal clock.
Moore made an important adjustment late in the season.
The Saints moved toward a cleaner progression-read system. Shough received immediate underneath options instead of carrying too many complicated pre-snap responsibilities. Checkdowns became part of the play’s design rather than a last-second emergency.
That helped Shough play faster and contributed to New Orleans’ improved finish.
Atlanta will test whether that progress is sustainable.
The Falcons do not need to sack Shough repeatedly. They need to make him hesitate, disrupt the timing of Moore’s offense and wait for one negative play to stop a drive.
New Orleans must prevent pressure from becoming possession-ending damage.
Film Room: How Moore Can Protect Shough
The first solution begins with Kelvin Banks Jr. and Taliese Fuaga.
Both tackles must keep Shough’s launch point clean and prevent Atlanta’s edge defenders from winning quickly. James Pearce Jr. possesses enough explosiveness to wreck long-developing passing concepts if New Orleans leaves its tackles isolated throughout the night.
Moore can provide assistance without turning the offense conservative.
Two-tight-end formations featuring Juwan Johnson and Oscar Delp would allow New Orleans to chip edge rushers before releasing receivers into the pattern. Delp’s combination of athleticism and blocking potential makes him particularly useful in those situations.
Moving pockets should also become part of the plan.
Bootlegs and designed rollouts can change Shough’s launch point, reduce interior congestion and take advantage of his mobility. Shough is not a run-first quarterback, but he moves well enough to threaten the edge or take free yardage when defenders turn their backs.
Moore should also continue using quick-game concepts.
Slants, speed outs, shallow crossers and running back screens would give Shough answers before pressure arrives. Those calls can force Atlanta to defend the entire width of the field rather than attacking a stationary quarterback.
The objective is not to hide Shough. It is to place him in control.
Moore Must Completely Repair the Goal-Line Offense
The Week 12 goal-line failures cannot be repeated.
New Orleans now has the personnel to establish a direct short-yardage identity without relying on gadget packages.
Etienne brings burst and home-run speed, but he is also capable of attacking a crease decisively. Kamara remains one of the league’s most intelligent runners. He understands blocking leverage and can locate small openings near the goal line.
The Saints should run behind their strongest blockers from under center. They can use motion to identify coverage, but the actual assignment must remain simple: create vertical movement and allow the running back to make one decisive cut.
Shough also demonstrated that he can help in short-yardage situations. Moore increasingly used under-center quarterback sneaks and designed power concepts late in 2025. Shough finished his rookie season with three rushing touchdowns.
Those calls reduced unnecessary exchanges and placed the ball directly in the quarterback’s hands.
Play-action should complement that approach. Once Atlanta begins attacking the interior gaps, Shough can fake the downhill run and target Johnson or Delp behind the linebackers.
Creativity still belongs in the red-zone plan. It should create easy answers—not introduce additional opportunities for confusion.
Shough Must Protect the “Inverted Red Zone”
The area between the opponent’s 20- and 35-yard lines can become an inverted red zone for young quarterbacks.
The offense is close enough to score points, but not always close enough for traditional red-zone concepts. A sack can move the team out of field-goal range. An interception can erase the entire possession.
Shough posted an encouraging 2-percent turnover-worthy-play rate during his rookie season. That suggests he generally protected the football well.
The timing of his mistakes created the problem.
His Week 18 interception came with New Orleans already positioned to score. The turnover did not merely end a drive. It gave Atlanta the opportunity to produce the winning points.
Moore and Shough need a firm situational rule in that area.
If the primary progression breaks down, Shough should locate the checkdown, use his legs for safe yardage or throw the ball away. The Saints cannot sacrifice three available points while chasing a difficult completion.
Protecting the football does not require passive quarterback play. It requires Shough to understand the value of the possession.
Jordyn Tyson Changes the Equation
Atlanta benefited from New Orleans’ limited receiving options during the second matchup.
That should not be the case in 2026.
Tyson, the eighth overall selection in the 2026 NFL Draft, gives the Saints another receiver capable of threatening man coverage. His presence should prevent opponents from tilting their entire coverage plan toward Olave.
Moore can use Olave’s route-running ability to attack one side of the field while creating isolation opportunities for Tyson on the other.
That becomes especially valuable in the intermediate area.
Routes between 10 and 19 yards can give Shough clean throwing windows without requiring him to hold the football for deep-developing plays. Johnson and Delp can control the middle, while Kamara and Etienne occupy linebackers underneath.
New Orleans did not possess that complete collection of answers against Atlanta last season.
Shough will have more options in 2026. He must use them without forcing the football.
Simplifying the Backfield Exchange
The opening fumble from Week 12 appeared to be a basic mistake, but it represented a broader concern.
Ballhandling details decide close games.
The Saints should simplify their mesh-point responsibilities, especially when using a two-back rotation. Traditional handoffs from under center allow the quarterback and running back to create a cleaner exchange than certain shotgun concepts.
That does not mean abandoning the shotgun. It means matching the formation to the situation.
Near the goal line or during critical short-yardage plays, the Saints should reduce moving parts. Shough must secure the snap, complete the exchange and allow the offensive line to determine the result.
Atlanta received an immediate scoring opportunity because New Orleans mishandled a routine action. The Saints cannot give their rival another gift.
Monday Night Football Makes This Personal
The first 2026 meeting will carry more meaning than an ordinary divisional game.
New Orleans will host Atlanta in Week 4 on Monday Night Football. The October 5 matchup will mark the Saints’ return to prime time and fall near the 20th anniversary of the Superdome’s historic reopening.
That 2006 reopening also came against the Falcons on Monday night. New Orleans won 23–3 and produced one of the most memorable moments in franchise history.
The 2026 Saints cannot recreate the historical significance of that night. They can honor it by playing with discipline, urgency and purpose.
A victory would give Moore and Shough their first win over Atlanta while establishing New Orleans as a legitimate NFC South threat.
A third consecutive loss would raise uncomfortable questions.
Has the short-yardage offense truly improved? Can Shough protect the football under late-game pressure? Can Moore outcoach a familiar divisional opponent when the margin disappears?
This rivalry will provide the answers.
Big Q’s Take
The Falcons did not prove they were dramatically better than the Saints in 2025.
They proved they were better when the games reached their most important moments.
Atlanta finished drives. New Orleans did not. Atlanta accepted field goals when necessary. The Saints allowed turnovers and sacks to erase scoring opportunities. Atlanta waited for mistakes and punished them.
The Saints have addressed several personnel problems.
Etienne upgrades the backfield. Tyson expands the passing game. Delp strengthens the tight-end room. Shough now has a full offseason as the established starter. Moore has an entire season of film identifying what his young quarterback handles well.
The remaining challenge is execution.
New Orleans cannot reach the 1-yard line and leave without a touchdown. Shough cannot turn pressure into drive-killing sacks. He cannot force the football while already in scoring range.
The Saints have enough talent to beat Atlanta. Now they must demonstrate the maturity to do it.
Why It Matters
A team cannot claim control of its future while its biggest rival controls the series.
The Saints are attempting to build a new era around Moore and Shough. That process requires more than statistical progress and encouraging offseason reports. It requires victories that matter to the Who Dat Nation.
Beating Atlanta on Monday Night Football would provide one.
It would demonstrate that Moore repaired his short-yardage plan. It would show that Shough learned from his late interception. It would establish that the new offensive additions can change the outcome of close divisional games.
Most importantly, it would end the excuses.
The Falcons swept the Saints during the developmental stage of the Moore-Shough partnership. They cannot be allowed to do it again.
Gee Bino is a senior writer and columnist for The Who Dat Daily, covering the New Orleans Saints, Pelicans, LSU athletics, and the Gulf South sports landscape. He specializes in roster construction, player development, salary cap strategy, and breaking news coverage. Follow The Who Dat Daily for daily news, analysis, and exclusive team coverage.
Can the Saints Really Have the NFL’s Next Breakout Offense? – The Who Dat Daily
Tyler Shough’s Conversation With Chris Long Reveals the Saints’ New Identity – The Who Dat Daily